Back to regularly scheduled programming!
November votes are here! This round features my own committee asking for a bigger toolkit (disclosure below) and the return of the financial transparency debate. Details:
1. Expand the CSMC Mandate to Cover Additional Penalty Cases
Vote: For (vote)
Rationale:
Disclosure: I’m a member of the CSMC, so I’m quite close to this one. Thing is: ~0.79 ETH in penalties and missed rewards across six CSM validators, and recovering ~0.45 ETH of it depended on the operator voluntarily compensating. We have the best node operator base in the world, but we can probably do with systems that don’t require goodwill.
Props to @Aleksandra_G for the clear mandate writeup.
2. Final Proposal (Version 2): Comprehensive Reporting & Audit Standards, Strategic Communications, and Budget Optimization for EGG 2027
Vote: Against (vote)
Rationale:
My full take is in the forum thread, but the short version: I support the intent (accountability to nudge better capital allocation) and still don’t believe we take meaningfully better decisions as tokenholders with another layer of financial transparency, since it costs a lot more to be 10% more transparent.
To @Cryp1’s credit, this version drops the $150–400k external audit that was my main objection and keeps the parts I like (sub-product P&L separation, monthly community-agenda forums), but those don’t need a Snapshot vote to happen. The mandated budget cuts and sunset criteria belong inside the EGG 2027 process, which is coming soon!